Chief Jess Mizer 1930-1936
Chief R. L. Vernon 1936-1968
Chief Erwin Gibbons 1968-1971
Chief F.L. Carder 1971-1973
Chief Jerry Davis 1973-1986
Chief Larry Gilkerson 1987-2006 (Larry remains a volunteer with the Brewster Fire Department...when he's not off vacationing!)
Chief Dale Starcher 2006-2009
Chief Rick Patterson 2009-2014
Chief Chris Colucy 2014-Present